All Star Game Tied After Nine Innings? What Happens to My Bet?

Submitted by Dan Shapiro on

Written by :

Dan Shapiro

Published on :

All Star Game Tied After Nine Innings?  What Happens to My Bet?

They just announced Tuesday that if the All-Star Game is tied after nine innings there will be a homerun hitting contest to determine the winner of the game.  The question is, what will happen to your bet as it's doubtful many of the sportsbooks have rules specific to this game.


Gambling911.com's Thomas Somach explained the process.

"Each team will supply three hitters for the contest and whoever gets the most homeruns wins game.

"So if the game is tied 3-3 after nine and the AL wins the homerun contest 2-1, is the final score 4-3 or 5-4? Would make a difference if you bet on the total of 7 1/2."

Somach offered up his hot winning trend for All-Star Games played on the West Coast earlier today.

"(The) All-Star game almost always goes under the total when it’s on the West Coast because the Game starts at 5 PM local time much of the game takes place during sunset when the ball is hard to see so hard to hit," Somach tells us.

In fact, all of the West Coast games were low scoring except for one.  There was another high scoring West Coast game but that was at the Kingdome in Seattle and indoors, therefore doesn't factor into this intriguing angle.

It should be noted that, in hockey if the game is tied 3 to 3 and it goes to a shoot out and one team wins the shoot out two to nothing, the final score is not 5 to 3 it is 4 to 3.

"I haven’t read anything about how baseball will handle this," Somach says.

There is likely to be plenty of controversy should it come down to this.

Somach is prepared to play the Amazing Kreskin once again.

"My prediction: if the tiebreaker homerun contest happens tonight and is popular with fans which it will be, I think MLB might go to this in the regular season."

He added: "It would be an exciting way to decide ties although they probably would not do it in the playoffs."

Unibet posted the following:

unibet-all-star-game.png

- Dan Shapiro, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Gambling911.com top news

Live Gambling News, Top Trending: Updates 24/7 - Sunday April 19, 2026

Live News: - Kash Patel Polymarket - Indiana Sweepstakes Casino Ban - Don Schlitz Dead - Kenny Rogers - The Gambler - Iran Conflict - Strait of Hormuz
Latest news

Live Gambling News, Top Trending: Updates 24/7 - Saturday April 18, 2026

Live News: - Don Schlitz Dead - Kenny Rogers - The Gambler - Bally's William Hill Acquisition - Iran Conflict - Strait of Hormuz - Prediction Markets - Tallahassee Gambling Bust
Kash Patel

FBI Director Kash Patel's Scary Polymarket Exit Chances Revealed: Half Say Out By April 30

  • Scathing article appearing in The Atlantic accuses FBI Director of "excessive drinking and unexplained absences"

  • Kash Patel responded on X Saturday saying he plans to take outlet to court

  • Traders at Polymarket are giving him just shy of a 50% chance of still being around by April 30

Sunny Mehta and the New Jersey Devils

Poker Pro, WSOP Bracelet Winner and Author Sunny Mehta Hired as GM for New Jersey Devils

Mehta was a key part of the Florida management group that helped deliver back-to-back Stanley Cups in 2024 and 2025