2025 MLB Comeback Player of the Year Award Odds

Submitted by Guest on

Written by :

Guest

Published on :

Who knew that MLB has had a Comeback Player of the Year Award for the last 20 years?!?!
betonline-250.png

It’s become a very controversial award in the NFL due to some voters voting for players coming off injury while others vote for a player that had a turnaround season.

Maybe we’re more aware about this award now because MLB wants to get more notice.

The oddsmakers at BetOnline.ag decided to open up odds this year for MLB Comeback Player of the Year.

The respective favorites are Mike Trout and Ronald Acuna Jr.

Side Note: Seems like Trout could’ve been a favorite the past five years!

These odds are fluid and subject to change.

2025 American League Comeback Player of the Year

Mike Trout

7/2

(+350)

 

Jacob deGrom

4/1

 

 

Shane McClanahan

9/2

(+450)

 

Felix Bautista

11/2

(+550)

 

Bo Bichette

7/1

 

 

Trevor Story

10/1

 

 

Evan Carter

14/1

 

 

Byron Buxton

18/1

 

 

Shane Bieber

22/1

 

 

Kyle Wright

25/1

 

 

Lance McCullers

25/1

 

 

Lucas Giolito

25/1

 

 

Luis Garcia

25/1

 

 

Liam Hendricks

28/1

 

 

Cristian Javier

28/1

 

 

Esteury Ruiz

40/1

 

 

Garrett Whitlock

40/1

 

 

Javier Baez

40/1

 

 

Jonathan Loaisiga

40/1

 

 

Anthony Rendon

66/1

 

 

Kyle Bradish

66/1

 

 

Matt Brash

66/1

 

 

 

 

 

 

2025 National League Comeback Player of the Year

Ronald Acuna Jr.

3/1

 

 

Sandy Alcantara

4/1

 

 

Spencer Strider

11/2

(+550)

 

Brandon Woodruff

7/1

 

 

Matt McLain

15/2

(+750)

 

Kodai Senga

9/1

 

 

Jung Hoo Lee

10/1

 

 

Justin Verlander

14/1

 

 

Tony Gonsolin

18/1

 

 

Christian Yelich

20/1

 

 

Dustin May

20/1

 

 

Jesus Luzardo

20/1

 

 

Eury Perez

22/1

 

 

Jordan Montgomery

22/1

 

 

Jordan Walker

22/1

 

 

Ronny Mauricio

33/1

 

 

Drey Jameson

50/1

 

 

Taijuan Walker

66/1

 

 

Related Content

Tyrese Maxey Player Prop Bets vs. Pacers October 28

Tyrese Maxey Player Prop Bets vs. Pacers October 28

25+ points: Tyrese Maxey has cleared this in all four regular-season games ahead of this one.
Fall Colorado Poker Championship — Bally's Black Hawk Now Underway

Fall Colorado Poker Championship — Bally's Black Hawk Now Underway

The 2026 Fall Colorado Poker Championship features a $200,000 guaranteed Main Event, a $100,000 guaranteed kickoff tournament and a $2,500 High Roller.
$5000 Bet Placed on Gina Hinojosa to Win the Texas Governor's Race at +215 Odds

$5000 Bet Placed on Gina Hinojosa to Win the Texas Governor's Race at +215 Odds

BetOnline has moved the odds on Hinojosa down even further from +215 to +185 over the last couple of hours Wednesday.
Margin of Victory Odds for Ashley Moody Now Available as Angie Nixon Odds Slashed in Florida Senate Race

Margin of Victory Odds for Ashley Moody Now Available as Angie Nixon Odds Slashed in Florida Senate Race

Ashley Moody's Margin of Victory was listed at 6.5% over/under as of Wednesday afternoon.