Matthew Stafford the New 2025-2026 NFL MVP Odds-on Favorite

Submitted by C Costigan on

Written by :

C Costigan

Published on :

Matthew Stafford

We have two new favorites this week. Matthew Stafford for MVP and Christian McCaffrey for Comeback Player of the Year favorite.

UP TO $250 IN FREE BETS + 100 Free Spins

Here are notes for each award along with some changes from the previous week:

  • MVP
    • Matthew Stafford has passed Drake Maye (on bye) as the favorite.
    • It’s basically a two-player race currently.
    • Josh Allen from 25/1 to 10/1.
    • Dak Prescott 12/1 to off the board.
    • Patrick Mahomes is off the board. Earliest this has happened during his career as a starter.
    • Jonathan Taylor is now off the board too.
  • Defensive Player of the Year
    • Myles Garrett is a massive favorite at -1600 (1/16).
    • Nik Bonitto from 40/1 to 16/1
  • Coach of the Year
    • Mike Vrabel remains the favorite.
    • Liam Coen from sixth at 25/1 to second at 17/4 (+425)
    • Kyle Shanahan from 28/1 to 11/1
    • Brian Schottenheimer from 18/1 to 100/1.
    • Shane Steichen from 25/1 to 100/1.
  • Offensive Rookie of the Year
    • Tetairoa McMillan remains the favorite and despite being on bye, he increased his lead. Probably due to poor stats of Egbuka.
    • Harold Fannin Jr. and Kyle Monangai are back on the board.
  • Defensive Rookie of the Year
    • Carson Schwesinger has expanded his lead.
    • Nick Emmanwori from fifth at 25/1 to second at 4/1.
    • Mason Graham, Mike Green and Nic Scourton are now off the board
  • Offensive Player of the Year
    • JSN is a bigger favorite now
    • Jahmyr Gibbs fifth at 66/1 to second at 4/1. He also passed Jonathan Taylor
    • Puka Nacua is back on the board.
    • George Pickens is now off the board.
  • Comeback Player of the Year
    • Christan McCaffrey is once again the favorite (despite being on bye) passing Dak Prescott.
MVP  
Matthew Stafford1/2 (-200)
Drake Maye2/1 
Josh Allen10/1 
Jordan Love11/1 
Bo Nix100/1 
Justin Herbert100/1 
Sam Darnold100/1 
Jaxon Smith-Njigba125/1 
   
Defensive Player of the Year  
Myles Garrett1/16 (-1600)
Micah Parsons13/2(+650)
Nik Bonitto16/1 
Will Anderson Jr.25/1 
Danielle Hunter33/1 
   
Coach of the Year  
Mike Vrabel (NE)1/2 (-200)
Liam Coen (JAX)17/4(+425)
Mike Macdonald (SEA)13/2(+650)
Ben Johnson (CHI)15/2(+750)
Kyle Shanahan (SF)11/1 
Dave Canales (CAR)16/1 
Sean Payton (DEN)33/1 
Sean McVay (LA)50/1 
Brian Schottenheimer (DAL)100/1 
Shane Steichen (IND)100/1 
   
Offensive Rookie of the Year  
Tetairoa McMillan5/8 (-160)
Jaxson Dart12/5(+240)
Emeka Egbuka11/2(+550)
Tyler Warren15/2(+750)
TreVeyon Henderson22/1 
Harold Fannin Jr.40/1 
Kyle Monangai50/1 
Quinshon Judkins50/1 
   
Defensive Rookie of the Year 
Carson Schwesinger1/10 (-1000)
Nick Emmanwori4/1 
Jalon Walker16/1 
Abdul Carter25/1 
Jihaad Campbell50/1 
Malaki Starks50/1 
Donovan Ezeiruaku66/1 
Derrick Harmon75/1 
Xavier Watts75/1 
   
Offensive Player of the Year  
Jaxon Smith-Njigba2/7 (-350)
Jahmyr Gibbs4/1 
Jonathan Taylor15/2(+750)
Puka Nacua16/1 
Christian McCaffrey20/1 
   
Comeback Player of the Year 
Christian McCaffrey4/7 (-175)
Dak Prescott6/5(+120)
Aidan Hutchinson28/1 
Rashee Rice75/1 
Stefon Diggs75/1 

- BetOnline Press

Related Content

Carson Beck to Throw a Touchdown on His First Offensive Drive Prop Bet - Panthers vs. Cardinals

Carson Beck to Throw a Touchdown on His First Offensive Drive Prop Bet - Panthers vs. Cardinals

Carson Beck, a third-round pick from Miami, will be under center for new Cardinals coach Mike LaFleur when Arizona hosts the Carolina Panthers for the first NFL exhibition game of the 2026 season Thursday night.
Carolina Panthers @ Arizona Cardinals Hall of Fame Game Betting Odds

Carolina Panthers @ Arizona Cardinals Hall of Fame Game Betting Odds

The exhibition schedule kicks off Thursday night with Carson Beck and the Arizona Cardinals facing Kenny Pickett and the Carolina Panthers in the Hall of Fame Game in Canton, Ohio.
Fantasy Rankings Are Now Part of NFL Betting

Fantasy Rankings Are Now Part of NFL Betting

NFL betting used to be built mostly around teams. Bettors looked at spreads, totals, moneylines, injuries, weather and coaching matchups. Those pieces are still there, but the modern football betting board is much more player-driven than it used to be.
Brendan Sorsby Supplemental Draft Round Odds Now Up

Brendan Sorsby Supplemental Draft Round Odds Now Up

Sorsby is officially declared for the NFL Supplemental Draft. The whole story is crazy, but the craziest part to us is that he gets to keep the $5 million in NIL money from Texas Tech.