Ninth Circuit of Appeals Judges Skeptical Over Prediction Markets Claim They Can Bypass State Laws

Submitted by Gilbert Horowitz on

Written by :

Gilbert Horowitz

Published on :

Legal
  • U.S. Circuit Judge Ryan Nelson bluntly rejected Crypto.com attorney Shay Dvoretzky’s argument that exchange-traded contracts differ in substance from sportsbook wagers

  • "You’re still setting odds and betting on outcomes… I don’t understand how you can say those are different"

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit judges expressed skepticism that sports-based event contracts differ meaningfully from traditional betting during April 16 oral arguments in a consolidated case involving North American Derivatives Exchange Inc. (Crypto.com), Robinhood, and Kalshi against Nevada.

U.S. Circuit Judge Ryan Nelson bluntly rejected Crypto.com attorney Shay Dvoretzky’s argument that exchange-traded contracts differ in substance from sportsbook wagers:

"This is sophistry to the nth degree… It’s still the house.”

When counsel argued that event contracts operate through market mechanisms rather than bookmaker odds, Nelson pushed back:

"You’re still setting odds and betting on outcomes… I don’t understand how you can say those are different.”

Nelson stopped him to read Rule 40.11, saying, “That is not… what 40.11 says.” He pointed to the recent Third Circuit ruling in favor of Kalshi, saying the court’s interpretation of the rule was a fundamental problem.

He read out loud: "A registered entity shall not list for trading or except through clearing any of the following… terrorism, assassination, war, gaming.”

Attorney Nicole Saharsky, representing Nevada, warned against the dramatic expansion of federal power.

"What plaintiffs… are urging is a severe intrusion on state sovereignty… making the CFTC the nation’s gaming regulator.”

The state argued that, taken to its logical conclusion, the approach would sweep in all sports betting:

 "All sports bets would qualify as swaps.”

“Swaps” are basically financial contracts that pay out based on whether an event happens.

Prediction market attorneys argued that the CEA’s definition of swaps clearly covers event-based contracts. Dvoretzky opened the hearing by saying:

"The Dodd-Frank Act defines swaps broadly to include contracts where payment turns on the occurrence… of an event associated with a potential financial… consequence.”

However, the court questioned whether that interpretation extends too far into territory historically regulated by the states. Nelson asked:

"Is there any suggestion that in Dodd Frank, in 2010… that they intended to transfer jurisdiction over sports gaming… away from the states to the CFTC?”

  • Gilbert Horowitz, Gambling911.com 

Related Content

VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW is pleased to announce Chumba Casino – the premier online social casino experience in the U.S. – has launched a new iOS app in the Apple App Store, giving players the brand’s full experience in a modern, state of the art native app.
Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Oklahoma's sweepstakes casino ban went into effect Sunday November 1.
Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

The most recent TrustPilot reviews of Winna.com are especially head scratching. All are one star interspersed with a few five star reviews that tend to lack in substance.
What's Up With those Crown Coins Better Business Bureau Complaints?  Update

What's Up With those Crown Coins Better Business Bureau Complaints? Update

Crown Coins is considered a leader in the US-facing sweepstakes casino sector with its site frequently appearing atop affiliate-created content appearing all over news feeds, often via real local city and regional digital newspaper feeds.