Written by :
Published on :
The warning appeared in a letter Kalshi's attorneys filed late Thursday, November 19, 2026, following a federal court decision returning the case to New York state court
"Kalshi's attorneys wrote: "There are serious defects in the ex parte relief previously sought by [James], including extraterritorial effects that extend well beyond this Court's jurisdiction"
ALBANY, N.Y. (Gambling911.com) - Kalshi issued a dire warning Friday that New York Attorney General Letitia James' lawsuit could effectively shut down its entire prediction-market exchange nationwide—not merely its operations in New York. The warning appeared in a letter Kalshi's attorneys filed late Thursday, November 19, 2026, following a federal court decision returning the case to New York state court. The prediction market itself is based out of New York.
What is the Letitia James' Lawsuit?
In her suit, James claims Kalshi operates an illegal gambling business under New York law.
The central question is whether Kalshi's sports event contracts are federally regulated financial derivatives or illegal sports wagers subject to state gambling laws.
New York's position is that Kalshi allows customers to wager money on the outcomes of sporting events without obtaining the gambling licenses required by the state.
The suit was originally filed in July.
“New York’s gambling laws protect children from underage betting and help combat gambling addiction," James said at the time.
She continued: “No matter what they call themselves, prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple.”
The state's broader argument is that labeling a gambling transaction a financial contract does not automatically exempt it from state gambling regulation.
Unlike licensed New York sportsbooks, Kalshi does not operate under a New York sports wagering license.
The suit includes eight causes of action based on alleged violations of New York's constitution, gambling statutes and the federal Wire Act.
New York alleges that Kalshi:
- Offers unlicensed gambling on sports, elections, entertainment and other events.
- Allows customers ages 18–20 to trade sports contracts despite New York's minimum age of 21 for mobile sports wagering.
- Avoids gambling taxes and regulatory obligations imposed on licensed sportsbooks.
- Exposes customers to gambling-related financial risks without complying with the state's consumer protection framework.
Because Kalshi is headquartered in New York, an injunction against activities conducted from the state could affect its operations nationwide.
In other words, New York's proposed temporary restraining order would restrict event-contract business conducted within or from New York, including contracts involving sports, culture, elections and other events.
Why Can't Kalshi Just Obtain a Sports Betting License Like DraftKings or FanDuel?
Theoretically, Kalshi could obtain a sports betting license, but they would be severely limited as to what can be offered on their platform.
Additionally, New York's licensing system uses a competitive selection process. Kalshi couldn't simply submit an application, pay a fee and automatically receive authorization. It would need an available licensing pathway, potentially involving an existing licensed operator or a future state selection process.
If Kalshi agrees to New York sportsbook regulation, it could weaken its broader argument that sports event contracts should be regulated exclusively by the CFTC.
Oh, and did we mention the state tax?
New York taxes online sportsbook operators at 51% of gross gaming revenue (GGR).
What Transpired on Friday, November 20?
There were several significant developments.
1. A federal judge returned New York's enforcement lawsuit to state court.
2. Kalshi requested an immediate hearing before any emergency restraining order could be issued.
3. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission sought emergency federal intervention to prevent New York from restricting Kalshi.
4. A federal judge rejected the CFTC's emergency request Friday evening.
The state is seeking substantial remedies.
- Requested remedy Potential consequence
- Injunction Stop unlicensed event-contract operations within or from New York
- Disgorgement Require Kalshi to surrender allegedly unlawful gains
- Financial penalties Up to three times the gains from allegedly illegal conduct
- Restitution Compensation for affected customers
Court filings reference approximately $36 billion in requested monetary relief, subject to accounting. That is not an award or established debt.
Kalshi maintains that it operates a federally regulated derivatives exchange overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
Could Kalshi Really Shut Down?
Kalshi specifically warned that New York's proposed restraining order could force it to liquidate open contracts nationwide and potentially cease operating its entire exchange.
In its November 20, 2026 court filings, Kalshi's attorney Sean Murphy warned: "The TRO would likely force the liquidation of all open positions, disrupting markets far beyond this State."
Kalshi's attorneys also wrote: "There are serious defects in the ex parte relief previously sought by [James], including extraterritorial effects that extend well beyond this Court's jurisdiction."
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission went even further. Its attorney Andrew Weisberg told a federal judge: "The temporary restraining order New York seeks would completely shut down Kalshi's operations nationwide."
Relocation Easier Said Than Done
And why can't Kalshi simply relocate to another state?
It's complicated.
Kalshi operates a CFTC-designated contract market. Moving its exchange operations could involve regulatory filings, infrastructure changes, clearing arrangements, personnel and compliance reviews.
Likewise, relocation would not automatically dispose of New York's existing lawsuit or its claims for alleged past violations. New York could also continue restricting contracts offered to its own residents.
- Aaron Goldstein, Gambling911.com
