Written by :
Published on :
Martingale produced more profitable sessions than fixed betting in a dice simulation, yet its average loss was almost three times larger. Across 2,000 sessions per strategy, the results showed how frequently finishing ahead can coexist with losing more money overall.
Two runs of the GambleTools Dice Strategy Simulator compared fixed betting with Martingale, the system that doubles a stake after a loss and resets it after a win. Each run contained 2,000 sessions, with a starting balance of 1,000 virtual credits and a limit of 1,000 rounds per session. Both used the same winning probability and theoretical return to player.
Martingale produced 1,168 profitable sessions, compared with 746 for fixed betting. Yet its average closing balance was 974.94 credits, below the fixed-bet average of 990.80. It also stopped 830 sessions early because the next required stake could not be covered.
These were simulated outcomes from two runs, not records of real-money gambling. They offer a concrete way to examine a familiar claim about betting systems: that frequently finishing ahead makes a strategy financially sound.
The same opening bank, different demands on it
Both runs used the GambleTools Dice preset, with Roll Under selected, a target of 49.50 and a winning probability of 49.5 per cent. The theoretical return to player, or RTP, was set to 99 per cent. A successful one-credit wager returned two credits, including the original bet.
The fixed-bet run staked one credit every round. Martingale started at one credit, increased the stake by 100 per cent after each loss and reset it after each win. No additional strategy limits were enabled. The available balance still constrained what it could wager.
| Setting | Fixed betting | Martingale |
| Starting balance per session | 1,000 credits | 1,000 credits |
| Starting stake | 1 credit | 1 credit |
| Winning probability | 49.5% | 49.5% |
| Theoretical RTP | 99% | 99% |
| Sessions | 2,000 | 2,000 |
| Maximum rounds per session | 1,000 | 1,000 |
| Stake after a loss | Remains at 1 credit | Doubles |
| Stake after a win | Remains at 1 credit | Resets to 1 credit |
RTP describes the expected share of total stakes returned as payouts over repeated play. It does not promise that a particular session will finish close to that figure. The UK Gambling Commission makes this distinction in its explanation of return to player, noting that the percentage applies across substantial play rather than each individual session.
A 99 per cent theoretical RTP therefore leaves a 1 per cent house edge. That percentage applies to money wagered, including credits repeatedly staked after earlier payouts. It is not a fixed deduction from the opening balance.
More profitable sessions, a lower average balance
The results separated the frequency of success from its financial value.
| Recorded result | Fixed betting | Martingale |
| Average final balance | 990.80 credits | 974.94 credits |
| Average net result per session | −9.20 credits | −25.06 credits |
| Profitable sessions | 746 of 2,000 | 1,168 of 2,000 |
| Share of sessions profitable | 37.3% | 58.4% |
| Sessions stopped early | 0 | 830 |
| Highest final balance | 1,098 credits | 1,540 credits |
| Lowest final balance | 898 credits | 0 credits |
| Largest stake used | 1 credit | 512 credits |
| Total rounds completed | 2,000,000 | 1,547,885 |
| Observed RTP | 99.08% | 99.37% |
Martingale increased the share of profitable sessions by 21.1 percentage points. Its average loss was nevertheless 15.86 credits larger per session, about 2.7 times the fixed-bet loss in these runs.
The apparent contradiction disappears once losses are included at their actual size. Counting profitable sessions gives equal weight to a session that gains one credit and one that gains hundreds. It also leaves the size of unsuccessful sessions out of the calculation.
An average closing balance incorporates both sides. Here, Martingale's losing sessions more than offset the gains from its more numerous profitable sessions.
The underlying calculation is expected value: each possible financial result is weighted by its probability. OpenStax's statistics text explains this method, including its application to games of chance. A high frequency of positive results can coexist with a negative average when the losses are sufficiently large.
The stake reached 512 credits
Martingale's progression starts quietly. From a one-credit opening bet, consecutive losses require stakes of two, four, eight and 16 credits. After nine straight losses, the stakes already lost total 511 credits. The next required bet is 512.
For a session beginning with 1,000 credits and no earlier gains, that leaves a balance of 489 credits. The next stake is already unaffordable.
Earlier profits can allow a session to place that 512-credit bet, as happened somewhere in the Martingale run. The largest recorded stake was more than half the original bank. A further loss would call for a 1,024-credit stake under the progression.
This arithmetic explains why removing an optional strategy limit does not give a player unlimited capacity to continue doubling. Every session still has a finite balance.
The fixed-bet run made no comparable increase in exposure per round. Its largest stake remained one credit, and every session reached the 1,000-round limit. Closing balances ranged from 898 to 1,098 credits. Martingale's wider range, from zero to 1,540, came with a much heavier demand on the bank during losing sequences.
An early stop did not necessarily mean an empty account
The Martingale run recorded 830 sessions stopped before the round limit, all because the next bet was unaffordable. That was 41.5 per cent of sessions when rounded to one decimal place.
Calling all 830 cases complete bankruptcies would misstate the evidence. A session can retain credits while lacking enough to place the next doubled stake. The lowest recorded final balance was zero.
The distinction matters when interpreting the strategy's practical demands. Continuing with a smaller wager would change the specified betting rule. Adding funds would change the starting resources available to the session. Neither action was part of this comparison.
Early stops also reduced the number of rounds actually played. Fixed betting completed all two million scheduled rounds. Martingale completed 1,547,885, about 22.6 per cent fewer. The comparison therefore measures what happened under the same starting resources and round ceiling, with affordability allowed to end a session.
The higher observed RTP needs context
Martingale's observed RTP was 99.37 per cent, above the fixed-bet result of 99.08 per cent. Both remained below 100 per cent. Neither changed the theoretical setting of 99 per cent.
The denominator is important. RTP compares payouts with total stakes, while the average closing balance measures what remained of the bank. Larger wagers can generate more turnover even when fewer rounds are completed.
The Gambling Commission's technical guidance on monitoring RTP calculates actual return from winnings and turnover. It also explains that measured results fluctuate and that combining different stake levels can give larger wagers disproportionate influence over the aggregate figure.
Total turnover was not recorded in the data available for this comparison. An exact comparison of credits wagered is therefore unavailable. Estimating it backwards from rounded RTP and balance figures would introduce unnecessary uncertainty.
For fixed betting, the expected loss is straightforward: 1,000 one-credit wagers at a 1 per cent house edge produce an expected loss of 10 credits per session. The recorded average loss of 9.20 credits was close to that benchmark.
Martingale changes the amount exposed on subsequent rounds. Under the same fixed probabilities and payout rules, doubling a wager increases the credits at risk without improving the expected return per credit staked.
What another run could change
These results describe one batch for each strategy. They do not establish that every repeat would produce the same average balance, stopping rate or ranking of observed returns. Because the strategies were tested in separate runs, the observed differences also reflect variation between random samples.
The analysis uses aggregate session results. Individual round histories and a random seed were not available, so the exact sequences cannot be reproduced from the reported data.
A further comparison could record turnover, median closing balances and the remaining balances of stopped sessions. Those measures would show more of the distribution than the mean and extremes alone. Repeated batches would also reveal how much the reported figures vary.
The present experiment already contains a useful detail for anyone assessing a claimed Martingale success rate. Its profitable-session count reached 1,168. The run also recorded 830 early stops, each triggered by the same problem: the balance could not cover the next bet.