Zayat Attorney Says Libel Suit is a Bunch of Horse S***: ‘Judge Will Throw It Out’

Submitted by Jagajeet Chiba on

Written by :

Jagajeet Chiba

Published on :

The attorney for a man claiming he is owed close to $2 million by American Pharoah owner Ahmed Zayat has himself filed a $10 million libel suit against him.  Gambling911.com first broke the story Monday afternoon and now the New York area media has been all over it

Joseph Bainton filed the suit claiming that Zayat had lied about the motives behind a suit he filed on behalf of his client Howard Rubinsky.  Mr. Rubinsky claims Zayat owes nearly $2 million in gambling debts to offshore betting shops he represented.

The suit further alleges that Zayat hints at an extortion plot.  Bainton calls that irresponsible and dangerous, something that could have the attorney disbarred if he were found to be involved in such a plot.

On Wednesday, Zayat’s attorney was forced to respond to the allegations, telling the Newark Star Ledger

Joseph Vann said in a prepared statement:  "We believe the lawsuit filed against our client today has no legal merit, we expect‎ it will be thrown out by the Court, and our client intends to file a malicious prosecution action after we prevail if warranted.”

Bainton dismissed Zayat's suggestion that he and Rubinsky were behind the stories generated by the lawsuit, claiming instead that Zayat's attorneys had filed court papers earlier this year that mentioned the previously undisclosed gambling debts.

American Pharoah hopes to become the first Triple Crown winner in nearly 40 years at this Saturday’s Belmont Stakes race. 

- Jagajeet Chiba, Gambling911.com

Related Content

2026 Early Kentucky Derby Odds Released

2026 Early Kentucky Derby Odds Released

We’re less than three weeks away from the 152nd Kentucky Derby.
Horse racing

Betting Against The Crowd In Kentucky Derby Markets: Is It Worth It?

On May 2, 2026, the Kentucky Derby returns to Churchill Downs in Louisville, Kentucky. The race continues its long-standing tradition of being held on the first Saturday in May. It will mark the 152nd time the Derby has been run.
Raid in Idaho at horse track by ICE

U.S. Citizens and Legal Residents Sue Over Aggressive Immigration Raid at Idaho Horse Racing Track

Three Idaho families who are U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents are suing after they and hundreds of others were detained for hours during an aggressive immigration raid at a rural horse racing track last year.
Horse racing

How We Follow Horse Racing Has Completely Changed

Horse racing has always been a sport built on routine. Certain days meant certain tracks, the form guide landed when it landed, and if you missed a race, you simply caught up later. Following the sport required a bit of commitment, a bit of patience, and often a bit of guesswork.